Maine Franchise Owners Association

You work hard in Maine! Together we can make Maine a better place for Business.

Click here to join the Maine Franchise Owners Association

  • Home
  • About Franchising
    • History of Franchising
    • Franchising in Maine
  • About MFOA
    • Why Join MFOA?
    • Terms of Use
  • Membership Info
    • Membership Levels
    • Sponsor Membership
    • Join Today
  • Contact Us
  • Join Today
  • Sponsor Directory

2019 Dickey’s BBQ Update

October 2, 2019 By admin

Photo by Don Sniegowski

Despite Churn, Franchises Continue to Sell

Once again, I am reporting on the very high churn rate for Dickey’s BBQ, yet the brand continues to sell a high number of franchises.  Why?  Do prospective franchisees not understand the numbers in the Franchise Disclosure Document?  And, why is the government continuing to guarantee loans to a brand with high charge-off rates and a large percentage of loans not current?

Last year, my article, “Is Dickey’s BBQ Franchising’s Next Quizno’s” and Restaurant Business Magazine’s Jonathan Maze’s “Dickey’s Barbeque Pit Closes 113 Units”, started this discussion.  I followed this with a second article, “Can Dickey’s Franchise Owners Survive”.

Now the 2019 Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) dated September 3, 2019[i], for the fiscal year ended May 31, 2019, has been released.  Has there been any improvement over the previous years?  In my opinion, the answer is no.  The churn rate, or disorderly attrition, continues to be over 27%, meaning over one in four franchisees leave the system every year, which is an alarming rate (even 10% would be a high turnover rate, in my opinion).Despite these numbers, Dickey’s franchisees continue to be able to access Small Business Administration guaranteed loans.  In a letter and attachments from the SBA to Senators Cortez Masto (NV) and Baldwin (WI)[ii], loans to Dickeys franchisees over the 10-year period ending March 31, 2019, showed 41 loans out of 246, or 16.7% of all Dickey’s franchisee loans, had been charged off.[iii]  Total Dickey’s franchisee loan approvals during that ten-year period totaled $69,682,800.  Total charge offs were $10,901,745, or 15.64% of the dollar value of all such loans.  The SBA share of the charge offs was $8,264,897, or 11.86%.  In addition, of the 132 active loans, 37, or 28%, were defined as “not current” by the SBA.  Yet, the SBA still approved 20 more loans in 2018, and 10 more loans in just the first quarter of 2019.

Knowing the data on Dickey’s BBQ, would banks approve loans to Dickey’s franchisees without the SBA guarantee?  And since the SBA 7(a) program is self-funding, how many other SBA borrowers are paying higher fees on their loans to cover these millions of dollars in losses?  Finally, when the losses do occur, the hardest hit is the franchisee owner that took out the loan.  For a loan default to reach the point where the SBA has to step in and cover the losses on the loan, the franchisee borrower (often a married couple) has reached the point where they cannot pay, meaning the franchisee has likely lost all their assets, including their home.

Situations like this are why Senator Cortez Masto (NV) has introduced S.2383, The Small Business Administration Franchise Loan Transparency Act of 2019.[iv]  This bill would require franchise brands to disclose first year revenue numbers, and first year numbers for “ceased operations” and transfers.  It would forbid third parties from providing revenue numbers to franchisees.  And, if a loan was obtained using false numbers received from the franchisor, the franchisor could be held liable for the loan.  Better transparency should allow for better underwriting, lowering charge off rates, and making more money available to more viable brands at reduced costs.  If you believe it is good to require better transparency for franchise brands to qualify for government guaranteed loans, call or write your Senators and ask them to cosponsor S.2383.

By Keith R. Miller, Franchisee Advocacy Consulting

[i] Dickey’s 2019 Franchisee Disclosure Document from the State of Minnesota website at  https://www.cards.commerce.state.mn.us/CARDS/security/search.do?documentId=%7b90B3496D-0000-CD3D-A01B-49AEF83E96C0%7d

[ii] Small Business Administration Letter to Senators Cortez Masto (NV) and Baldwin (WI) dated September 19, 2019, from Dianna L. Seaborn, Director, Office of Financial Assistance.

[iii] SBA Charge Off Procedures Summary & Suggested Wrap-up Report, at https://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/bank_wrapup_report.pdf

[iv] S.2383, The Small Business Administration Franchise Loan Transparency Act of 2019, text at https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/116/s2383/text

Filed Under: Failed Franchising, Fair Franchising, Featured, Franchise Economics, Franchising, Government Relations, SBA Loans, Transparency Tagged With: Fair Franchising, franchise finance, franchise owners, franchisees, franchising, SBA, SBA Backed Loan

Search Maine Franchise Owners Website

Recent Posts

  • FTC Commissioner Chopra Talks Franchise Issues on CNBC September 25, 2020
  • Schakowsky, Scanlon, Jayapal Send Letter to FTC September 25, 2020
  • Senator Cortez Masto (NV) Sends Letter to FTC Concerning Covid-19 Issues May 1, 2020
  • Keith Miller Testifies in Oregon, House Interim Committee On Business and Labor December 1, 2019
  • 2019 Dickey’s BBQ Update October 2, 2019
  • Senator Cortez Masto Introduces SBA Franchise Loan Transparency Act July 31, 2019
More from our Newsroom

Twitter Feed @MaineFOA

Maine Franchise Owners Follow

Representing Maine Franchise Owners

MaineFOA
mainefoa Maine Franchise Owners @mainefoa ·
1 May 2020

Senator Cortez Masto (NV) Sends Letter to FTC Concerning Covid-19 Issues http://mainefranchiseowners.org/senator-cortez-masto-nv-sends-letter-to-ftc-concerning-covid-19-issues/

Reply on Twitter 1256085100032212992 Retweet on Twitter 1256085100032212992 1 Like on Twitter 1256085100032212992 1 Twitter 1256085100032212992
Retweet on Twitter Maine Franchise Owners Retweeted
fairfranchising Fair Franchising Initiative @fairfranchising ·
21 Mar 2020

Hotel Small Business owner's first priority is their Millions of Great employees and their families. Small Business Hotel Owners want to help the federal government in efforts to fight Covid-19 @SpeakerPelosi @senatemajldr @SenSchumer

Reply on Twitter 1241422600317939726 Retweet on Twitter 1241422600317939726 5 Like on Twitter 1241422600317939726 5 Twitter 1241422600317939726
mainefoa Maine Franchise Owners @mainefoa ·
1 Mar 2020

Our Government Protects All Consumers… Except Franchisees! - American Association of Franchisees & Dealers https://www.aafd.org/our-government-protects-all-consumers-except-franchisees/

Reply on Twitter 1233996937524723717 Retweet on Twitter 1233996937524723717 Like on Twitter 1233996937524723717 1 Twitter 1233996937524723717
mainefoa Maine Franchise Owners @mainefoa ·
1 Mar 2020

Registration is now open for 2020 CFA Registration is now open for 2020 CFA Day! Join us in DC on May 20 for an important day on the Hill. http://www.magnetmail.net/actions/email_mobile_web_version.cfm?recipient_id=743713135&message_id=18213463&user_id=NFA_&jobid=47068265

Reply on Twitter 1233994456967204866 Retweet on Twitter 1233994456967204866 Like on Twitter 1233994456967204866 1 Twitter 1233994456967204866
mainefoa Maine Franchise Owners @mainefoa ·
1 Mar 2020

This is a perfect example of the type of legislation needed in Maine to protect local franchise owners.

Keith R Miller @FranchiseeAdvoc

Thank you Rep. Chris Mattos and the 9 bipartisan additional sponsors for introducing Vermont H.890, a comprehensive fair franchising bill. https://www.linkedin.com/posts/keith-miller-a42a5853_draft-bill-template-activity-6638858502699831296-4bNC

Reply on Twitter 1233993694178447361 Retweet on Twitter 1233993694178447361 2 Like on Twitter 1233993694178447361 2 Twitter 1233993694178447361
Load More

Franchise Links of Interest

Franchise News: Blue MauMau

Maine Small Business Association

Maine Offices of SCORE

American Association of Franchisees & Dealers

Coalition of Franchisee Associations

Franchisee Advocacy Consulting

New England Franchise Association

Unhappy Franchisee

© · Maine Franchise Owners Association · 415 Congress Street, Suite #202, Portland, ME 01401 · 207-274-2046 | Mobile Membership Site: MediaRight Technologies